Bert Baumgaertner

Bert Baumgaertner

Professor of Philosophy, University of Idaho Modeling Core Co-Director, Institute for Modeling Collaboration & Innovation Co-Founder, AI Ethics and Inquiry Outfit

About

I am a Professor of Philosophy at the University of Idaho. My work is situated at the intersections of cognitive science, philosophy, complex systems, and computational modeling. I am particularly interested in how scientists use diverse modeling techniques to understand the impacts of determinants of belief formation on complex biological and social phenomena.

My research explores questions about standards of evidence and their connections to opinion dynamics. I often use agent-based models and network theory as methodological tools, as well as survey studies. I am highly collaborative and interdisciplinary; my preference is to focus on questions that interest me rather than worry about disciplinary boundaries.

More recently, my work has expanded into analogy and metaphor as windows into human cognition and AI limitations. The MARC project (Metaphor Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus) uses community-created puzzles to probe what humans can do that AI systems cannot, and doubles as a tool for teaching AI literacy and ethics. I have also been investigating standards of evidence across political and scientific domains, and the philosophical and ethical dimensions of large language models and generative AI.

Research Areas

Opinion Dynamics & Social Epistemology

Modeling how beliefs form and spread through populations. Work on the preference for belief, echo chambers, reflective equilibrium, and how network structure shapes collective knowledge production.

Disease-Behavior Models

Computational models linking behavioral responses to epidemic dynamics. Research on risk tolerance, vaccination attitudes, and how transient prophylaxis drives epidemic waves.

Standards of Evidence

Investigating how individuals assess and gather evidence across scientific and political domains, including the effects of ideology and cognitive reflection on evidence-seeking behavior.

Analogy, Metaphor & AI Benchmarking

The MARC project explores how metaphorical reasoning reveals fundamental gaps between human and artificial intelligence. This work connects philosophy of language, cognitive science, and AI evaluation.

AI Literacy & Ethics

Building frameworks and tools for understanding generative AI, including its limits, biases, and societal impacts. Developing pedagogical approaches that make AI literacy accessible to non-technical audiences.

MARC: Metaphor Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus

MARC extends François Chollet's Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC) by pairing visual grid-based puzzles with metaphorical natural language hints. The core insight: humans can leverage metaphors to solve novel puzzles with remarkable ease, while AI systems struggle—exposing a fundamental gap in machine intelligence around fluid reasoning, perspective-shifting, and genuine understanding.

What MARC enables

Research. MARC provides a platform for studying how metaphorical reasoning works in humans and where it breaks down in AI. Each puzzle probes intentionality, agency, and the capacity for analogical thinking—capacities that remain beyond current AI systems.

AI Literacy & Ethics. Because anyone can create a MARC puzzle, it democratizes AI benchmarking. Students and non-specialists can directly engage with the question of what makes human intelligence distinctive, without needing technical training. The project serves as a teaching tool for critical thinking about AI capabilities and limitations.

Community. MARC puzzles are community-created and community-driven. Campus competitions and open submission foster broad participation across disciplines.

Selected Presentations

Most recent first. * Invited   ** Peer-reviewed

"Metaphor in the Machine: From Source to Target Domains without Dogmas about Conceptual Structure"Invited
Pacific American Philosophy Association, April 2026
"The Dark Room and the Ruthless Curiosity it Demands: Graduate Research in the Age of Agentic AI"Invited
ENVS 5010 Seminar Series, College of Natural Resources, University of Idaho, March 23, 2026
"A Formal Framework for How Inferential Commitments Create Deep Disagreements"
Computational Social Philosophy Seminars, March 23, 2026
"Metaphors We Intend With: Teaching AI Alignment Through Puzzles"Peer-reviewed
AI and Data Ethics: Philosophy and Pedagogy, University of Southern California, March 6–7, 2026
"Bots as Foils: Real Students Learn by Teaching AI Students"Peer-reviewed
University of Idaho Student Success Symposium: Ignite and Elevate, February 27, 2026
"How Will Our Ability to Access PhD++ Expertise at $20 a Month Impact 'Modeling Collaboration and Innovation'?"
IMCI Brown Bag Lunch Series, February 23, 2026
"The Grasshopper's Utopia: AI, Games, and the Future You're Playing Into"Invited
Vandal Gaming Convention, University of Idaho, February 28, 2026
"MARC Your Human Intelligence"Invited
University of Idaho POP Talks, October 2025 — Watch video
"EASY for Humans, HARD for AI: Metaphor Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus"Invited
Malcolm Renfrew Interdisciplinary Colloquium, University of Idaho, September 2, 2025
"Chatbots and Misinformation: The Semantic Turn, for Better and Worse"Invited
IMCI Brown Bag Lunch Series, University of Idaho, January 13, 2025
"AI Literacy — What Is and Isn't Working"Invited
Institute for Interdisciplinary Data Sciences — AI Literacy Series, University of Idaho, November 7, 2024
"AI Literacy for Everyone Who Learns and Inquires"Invited
The Renfrew Colloquium (joint with Casey Johnson), University of Idaho, October 22, 2024
"Standards of Evidence: Disease Dynamics and Human Evidence Gathering"
University of Idaho, October 1, 2024 (non-presenting co-author)
"LLMs, Bias and Ethical Dilemmas"Invited
Joint lecture with Casey Johnson in Boyu Zhang's graduate NLP course, April 29, 2024
"AI Literacy — A Discussion Spark in Using AI in Critical Thinking"Invited
Generative AI in Higher Education in Idaho, April 19, 2024
"Humanities Takeover: Values and the Work Towards AI Literacy"Invited
Institute for Interdisciplinary Data Sciences Seminar Series, April 18, 2024

Selected Publications

For a complete list, see my CV or Google Scholar.

Evaluating Evidentiary Standards in the Realm of Citizen Policy Evaluation
Justwan, F., Baumgaertner, B., McBrayer, M., Bindley, J.*, Benitez, A.*, Haile, K.*, Kludt-Painter, B.* (2026). Social Science Quarterly.
View publication
The Causes and Consequences of Public Misperceptions about the Origins of the Russo-Ukrainian War
Justwan, F., Berejikian, J.D., Baumgaertner, B. (2026). International Political Science Review.
View publication
The Effects of Ideology and Cognitive Reflection on Evidence Gathering Behavior in the Political Domain
Justwan, F., Baumgaertner, B. (2025). PLoS ONE 20(12): e0338088.
View publication
Heterogeneous Risk Tolerance, In-groups and Epidemic Waves
Tovissode, C., Baumgaertner, B. (2024). Frontiers in Applied Mathematics and Statistics.
View publication
Search is a Hammer, Generative Chat is a Loom; Beware the Technological Attribution Error
Baumgaertner, B., duBois, Z. (2024). In: Social Computing and Social Media. HCII 2024.
View publication
Precedent and Rest Stop Convergence in Reflective Equilibrium
Baumgaertner, B., Lassiter, C. (2024). Synthese.
View publication
Convergence and Shared Reflective Equilibrium
Baumgaertner, B., & Lassiter, C. (2023). Ergo.
View publication
The Logical Structure of Experiments Lays the Foundation for a Theory of Reproducibility
Buzbas, E.O., Devezer, B., Baumgaertner, B. (2023). Royal Society Open Science.
View publication
The Preference for Belief, Issue Polarization, and Echo Chambers
Baumgaertner, B., Justwan, F. (2022). Synthese.
View publication
Meddling in the 2016 Elections and Satisfaction with Democracy in the US
Justwan, F., Baumgaertner, B., Curtright, M.* (2022). Political Studies.
View publication
Transient Prophylaxis and Multiple Epidemic Waves
Tyson, R.C., Marshall, N.M.*, Baumgaertner, B. (2022). AIMS Mathematics.
View publication
The Effects of COVID-19 on Political Efficacy
McBrayer, M., Baumgaertner, B., Justwan, F. (2022). American Politics Research.
View publication
Risk of Disease and Willingness to Vaccinate in the United States: A Population-Based Survey
Baumgaertner, B., Ridenhour, B.J., Justwan, F., Carlisle, J.E., Miller, C.R. (2020). PLOS Medicine.
View publication
Voter Models and External Influence
Majmudar, J.R., Krone, S.M., Baumgaertner, B.O., Tyson, R.C. (2020). The Journal of Mathematical Sociology.
View publication
The Timing and Nature of Behavioural Responses Affect the Course of an Epidemic
Tyson, R., Baumgaertner, B., Hamilton, S.*, Lo, A., Krone, S. (2020). Bulletin of Mathematical Biology.
View publication
The Effect of Trust and Proximity on Vaccine Propensity
Justwan, F., Baumgaertner, B., Carlisle, J.E., Carson, E.*, Kizer, J.* (2019). PLoS ONE.
View publication
Scientific Discovery in a Model-Centric Framework: Reproducibility, Innovation, and Epistemic Diversity
Devezer, B., Nardin, L.G., Baumgaertner, B., Buzbas, E. (2019). PLoS ONE.
View publication
Spatial Opinion Dynamics and the Effects of Two Types of Mixing
Baumgaertner, B., Fetros, P.*, Tyson, R., Krone, S. (2018). Physical Review E.
View publication

Teaching

Regular Undergraduate Courses

  • PHIL 2010: Critical Thinking
  • PHIL 2020: Introduction to Symbolic Logic
  • Rotating: Decision Theory, Phil Language, Theory of Knowledge, Metaphysics

Seminars & Special Topics

  • PHIL 361: Professional Ethics — Generative AI
  • PHIL 4040: Rational Choice and Strategic Interactions

Course materials and syllabi are available for current students on the university's learning management system. Prospective students interested in course content can contact me directly via email.